In a recent drug case before the New York Appellate Division, Second Department, the defendant asked the court to reconsider the lower court’s denial of his motion to suppress the evidence that he was arrested in possession of. Originally, the defendant was convicted of criminal possession of marijuana and criminal…
Articles Posted in NARCOTICS
When Can a Police Officer Legally Frisk a Suspect in New York?
We have written extensively about the rights of citizens involved in street encounters with the police and the four tiers of intrusion based upon the level of suspicion that the police have. According to New York law, an officer may rightfully frisk a person when the officer has a “reasonable…
Probable Cause in New York Drug Cases When an Officer Cannot Confidently Identify the Object “Changing Hands”
When a police officer suspects that he witnesses the exchange of drugs for sale, can he arrest a suspect even if he’s unable to confidently identify the object that changed hands? According to New York case law, the answer is yes. A recent case before the New York Appellate Division,…
What Happens When a Judge Exerts Too Much Influence During Trial?
In criminal trials, juries must reach unanimous verdicts, which means all jurors must find a defendant guilty in order for the defendant to receive a guilty verdict. In a perfect world, jurors are able to deliberate and come to a verdict without the influence of the judge’s opinion regarding the…
Using the Right Standard in New York Traffic Stop Cases
As we have written about extensively, New York recognizes 4 levels of police intrusions during street encounters. Under New York law, when a police officer conducts a traffic stop, the officer cannot unnecessarily prolong the stop. If an officer does keep the driver beyond a reasonable amount of time, he…
Searches and Seizures of Parolees in New York: What You Need to Know
What are the rights of a parolee when an officer wants to conduct an invasive search or seizure? In New York, recent case law explored this very question, looking at the circumstances under which a defendant can successfully challenge a search based on his constitutional right to privacy. According to…
New York Police Officers’ “Community Caretaking” Role in Traffic Stops
We have previously written that police officers, in New York and elsewhere, have what is called a “community caretaking” duty. This means that officers are not only obligated to enforce the law, but they also must assist an individual when they notice that he or she needs help. Recently, a…
Right to Privacy in Bodily Searches in New York
Under the Fourth Amendment, individuals have a right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures. The word “unreasonable” can have different meanings in different contexts, but a recent case coming out of the Supreme Court of New York, Third Department, provides interesting case law for one of these contexts.…
Defendant in New York Drug Case Unsuccessfully Asks for Suppression of Incriminating Evidence
In a January 2024, New York Drug case before the Supreme Court of New York, Third Department, a defendant filed an appeal of the lower court’s denial of his motion to suppress. The defendant took issue with a police officer’s search of his person, arguing the officer did not have…
New York Court Reaches Pro-Defendant Decision in Narcotics-Detection Dog Case, Ruling that Sniffing Does Indeed Constitute a Search
In a recent drug case in New York, the Court of Appeals, New York’s highest Court held that using a narcotics-detection dog to sniff a criminal suspect’s body is defined as a “search.” Before this case, New York case law was unclear about whether this specific action constituted a search,…